← Articles

Nobody Wins: Why Storage Auctions Are Broken (and Why There's No Easy Fix)

A manager's honest take on a system that works for almost no one

Storage auctions aren't what people see on TV.

The idea of a storage auction isn't even fun. It's the last step of a process nobody wanted to get to. I've written about the three seats in the room. This time I'm saying the harder part out loud: I don't think anybody really wins.

Why auctions exist at all

Someone buys a storage facility to rent units. When a unit isn't renting anymore, it has to be turned.

If the tenant stops paying and goes quiet, the legal route is a lien sale. That's an auction. The tenant agrees to the lien in the rental agreement, and the facility uses a non-court process to sell the contents [1].

An industry lawyer puts it plainly: operators "are in business to rent units, not sell tenant property" [1]. The facility doesn't want your stuff. It wants the space back.

It doesn't happen to most people. The Self Storage Association says operators sell roughly 1% to 3% of leased spaces a year [2]. That's an industry group's number. But for the 1% to 3%, it's everything.

Three losers

Loser 1: The facility

The facility loses on either side of it. Either the unit sells for less than what's owed, or nobody bids and the facility has to dispose of the contents itself [1].

How much less? Industry sources disagree. In a 2012 poll of 400 operators, 47% said they were lucky to get back 25 cents on the dollar [3]. A 2017 trade article said about 50 cents [4]. Industry testimony in 2023 said 30 cents [2].

And if the unit sells for more than what's owed, the facility doesn't get to keep the extra. It has to hold it for the tenant. Here's how I put it:

"Imagine being stuck with someone's stuff, having to auction it when all you wanna do is re-rent it. Then once the auction is done you only get what you were owed, and now you have to hold their money for a period of time. It's insane."

How long? It depends on the state. Some hold for 90 days. Some hold for as long as three years [5][6][4]. After that, the money goes to the state, goes to the county, or the facility keeps it, depending on where you are [4]. And holds aren't getting shorter: one state just doubled its hold from six months to one year [7].

The money is the tenant's, so I get it. But surplus is unusual [1]. That's a lot of paperwork for something that rarely happens.

Loser 2: The tenant

The tenant loses their stuff. Sometimes that's furniture they can replace. Sometimes it's not.

In one widely reported case in October, a woman lost nearly everything she owned, including her stillborn son's ashes. A city payment-assistance error got her request denied. The unit was sold eight days after she applied for help, and the denial came seven days after the sale [8]. Advocates want a law to pause auctions while an application is pending. It stalled this year, and supporters plan to bring it back in January [9].

I'm not saying that's typical. I'm saying it's real.

Loser 3: The winning bid

And if the tenant doesn't lose, because they don't care and it was just trash, then there's a third loser: the winning bid. If it was all trash anyway, they're out the bit of money they spent hoping to find something good.

Now, a buyer can absolutely win. It's no different than someone buying crypto or stocks and hitting it, versus someone who loses their whole portfolio. That's the only winner, and that's fine.

In one week in November, a public tracker counted 10,127 verified online sales with a median price of $130. Units with one to four bids had a median of $20 [10]. I couldn't find reliable data on what buyers earn.

One difference from stocks: the buyer chose the gamble. The tenant didn't.

When auctions go right

Some good does come out of auctions. It's just rarer than the stories.

These are real. But they happen when somebody gets lucky or somebody cares. Neither one is a system.

The hard cases

People think that by just ghosting facilities when money is owed, the stuff is just handled.

Sometimes, in their eyes, it is. If they're doing that, there likely isn't anything sentimental in there. Industry testimony says, anecdotally, that many sales involve tenants who took out their valuables first [2].

But the facility doesn't always know somebody died. What if they don't have any family? What if they die and the facility never finds out? Or what if the family has no idea they ever had a storage unit?

When a tenant dies, rent keeps running. A family member generally needs a death certificate and a court order naming them administrator or executor before the facility can let them in, and unpaid charges can still lead to a sale [20].

It's a lot of back and forth. The way it's currently handled is broken. But I'm not sure there is any real fix, either.

What helps a little

None of these fixes the system. Each one helps some people some of the time.

  1. An alternate contact at move-in. At least one state already requires the rental agreement to ask. The contact gets no access rights unless the agreement says so [21]. It's cheap, and it gives the facility one more person to call.
  2. A pause after a death. One operator publishes a policy of waiting an extra 30 days before starting the lien process once it's told a tenant has died [22]. It only works if somebody tells them.
  3. A settlement ladder before the sale. Full payment, then a signed payment plan, then a reduced "empty it and sign a release" deal. Operators and lawyers already describe versions of this [23][24]. The risk is teaching people to wait.
  4. Returning surplus quickly, where the law allows. But some states require a sworn no-other-liens affidavit first [25], and another lienholder might have a claim [4]. And the tenant has to be findable.

Sounds nice, but

A memory box. Staff pull photos, papers and keepsakes out of the unit before the sale and hold them for the family. It sounds great.

But where is the facility supposed to store these things? If a facility has hundreds of doors, where do they keep the stuff? It's a huge headache. They don't want your stuff. They want to rent the space. Period.

Paying tenants a share of every sale. Feels fairer, but the facility is already recovering well under a dollar on the dollar [3][4][2]. It just moves the loss.

A reserve price at the amount owed. Then more units don't sell, and the facility disposes of them itself. It's a trade, not a fix [23].

So is it fixable?

I don't know. Almost every fix moves the pain from one seat to another. The facility wants the unit rented, the tenant wants their things, the buyer wants to find something good. The auction can't give all three.

What I do know is that most of the damage happens when nobody knows what's going on: a tenant who goes quiet, a family who never heard about the unit, a facility with an old phone number.

If you have a unit

Rules vary by state. This isn't legal advice.

Which seat are you closest to, and is there a fix I haven't thought of?


Want the rest of the story? I wrote a whole book on how I run storage facilities without being there every day: Boots on the Ground, at mdlake.gumroad.com/l/mijzsl. If you're dealing with a unit right now, grab the free "First 72 Hours" checklist at mdlake.gumroad.com/l/gzsova. And for the full auction walk-through, my free auction guide is at mdlake.gumroad.com/l/hmbzqc.

Sources

  1. Inside Self-Storage, "The Self-Storage Self-Help Remedy: An Overview of the Lien-Sales Process" (Oct 5, 2023). https://www.insideselfstorage.com/legal-issues/the-self-storage-self-help-remedy-an-overview-of-the-lien-sales-process
  2. Oregon Self Storage Association and Self Storage Association, testimony on SB 862 (Apr 24, 2023). https://olis.oregonlegislature.gov/liz/2023R1/Downloads/PublicTestimonyDocument/94050 (industry advocacy; "1% to 3%" and "$.30 on the dollar" are industry-reported)
  3. Inside Self-Storage, "Poll: Self-Storage Auctions Help Facility Operators Recoup Barely 25 Percent of Money Owed" (July 10, 2012). https://www.insideselfstorage.com/associations/poll-self-storage-auctions-help-facility-operators-recoup-barely-25-percent-of-money-owed
  4. Mini-Storage Messenger, "Surplus Uncertainties" (May 1, 2017). https://www.modernstoragemedia.com/msm-exclusives/surplus-uncertainties
  5. Stitch Storage, "What Happens to Surplus Lien Sale Proceeds" (Oct 19, 2026). https://stitchstorage.com/guides/what-happens-to-surplus-lien-sale-proceeds (a software vendor's guide)
  6. Colorado Revised Statutes 38-21.5-103 (excess proceeds held three years). https://law.justia.com/codes/colorado/title-38/liens/article-21-5/section-38-21-5-103/
  7. Inside Self-Storage, "Washington State Expands Holding Period for Unclaimed Self-Storage Lien-Sale Proceeds" (July 22, 2025). https://www.insideselfstorage.com/legal-issues/washington-state-expands-holding-period-for-unclaimed-self-storage-lien-sale-proceeds
  8. FOX 5 New York, "NYC error leads to auction of storage unit containing son's ashes" (Oct 8, 2026). https://www.fox5ny.com/news/brooklyn-mother-storage-unit-auctioned-city-error-nyc-dss-storage-assistance-error-nyc
  9. New York City Bar, "Protecting the Belongings of Homeless New Yorkers: Shavon's Law" (status of S.9870). https://www.nycbar.org/issues-policy/advocacy-campaigns/shavons-law/
  10. Storage auction price tracker, "Storage Auction Prices: Week of November 9, 2026." https://storagesauce.com/storage-auction-report (one week of online auctions; one tracker's count)
  11. Inside Self-Storage, guest post "Dread Reduction: Online Auctions Ease the Self-Storage Lien Burden" (Sept 20, 2013), by a California operator and forum moderator. https://www.insideselfstorage.com/self-storage-industry-news/dread-reduction-online-auctions-ease-the-self-storage-lien-burden (one operator's account)
  12. OpenTech Alliance press release, "Self Storage Operators Achieve 39% Lien Loss Recovery Rate on StorageTreasures Platform" (2024). https://opentechalliance.com/blog/self-storage-operators-achieve-39-lien-loss-recovery-rate-on-storagetreasures-platform-surpassing-8-8-million-in-recovered-rent/ (the platform owner's own release; one month, Feb 2024)
  13. NewsChannel 5 (WTVF), "Bedford County family reunited with precious items after storage unit auction." https://www.newschannel5.com/news/bedford-county-family-reunited-with-precious-items-after-storage-unit-auction
  14. WKRG News 5, "Fairhope Army veteran's ashes discovered in storage unit, returned to granddaughter" (Sept 22, 2026). https://www.wkrg.com/baldwin-county/fairhope-army-veterans-ashes-discovered-in-storage-unit-returned-to-granddaughter/
  15. Texas Self Storage Association, "Legal Q&A: Unit Access, Records Release, Employee Unit Rental, Online Auctions, Overlocking" (TSSA legal counsel, Question 4). https://www.txssa.org/Members/Online/Blog/Legal/Legal-Advice-Tenant-Access-Requests-for-Auction-Buy-Backs.aspx
  16. ABC15 Arizona, "Phoenix Man Buys Storage Unit for $20, Finds $16,000 Inside." https://www.abc15.com/positivelyarizona/phoenix-man-buys-storage-unit-for-20-finds-16000-inside
  17. CNBC Make It, "18-year-old started a side hustle selling 'treasures' from abandoned storage units" (Aug 12, 2026). https://www.cnbc.com/make-it/2026/08/12/teens-side-hustle-flipping-storage-units-brings-in-135000-a-year.html (revenue figures from documents CNBC reviewed; revenue is not profit)
  18. Reality Blurred, "Storage Wars fake? Producer admits scripting lines, moving items between lockers" (Dec 13, 2012). https://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/2012/12/storage-wars-beers-admits-staging-scripting/
  19. The Hollywood Reporter, "A&E Responds to Allegation That 'Storage Wars' Is Rigged" (Jan 28, 2013). https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/business-news/a-e-responds-allegation-storage-416006/
  20. Inside Self-Storage, "Tenant Death in Self-Storage: Legal Options for Facility Operators." https://www.insideselfstorage.com/legal-issues/tenant-death-in-self-storage-legal-options-for-facility-operators
  21. Kansas Statutes 58-816 (rental agreement must ask about an alternative contact). https://ksrevisor.gov/statutes/chapters/ch58/058_008_0016.html
  22. 10 Federal Storage, "Storage and an Estate: What To Do First" (one operator's published policy). https://10federalstorage.com/storage-scenarios/estate
  23. Inside Self-Storage, "What Would You Do? Self-Storage Auction Dilemmas" (Mar 9, 2013). https://www.insideselfstorage.com/iss-brand/what-would-you-do-self-storage-auction-dilemmas
  24. Mini-Storage Messenger, "Late Again: Managing Chronically Delinquent Tenants" (Feb 9, 2025). https://www.modernstoragemedia.com/msm-exclusives/late-again-managing-chronically-delinquent-tenants
  25. Missouri Revised Statutes 415.415 (affidavit that no other liens exist before surplus is paid). https://codes.findlaw.com/mo/title-xxvi-trade-and-commerce/mo-rev-st-415-415/
  26. The manager's own experience, as in the earlier article "One Gavel, Three Seats."
  27. 50 U.S.C. 3958, Enforcement of storage liens. https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/119-142/t50/s3958/

Not legal advice. Rules on notices, sales and leftover money vary by state. Check your state's law and your rental agreement.

Get the book$11.99